Newsletters

Menu

Search

Follow us

fb-roundinsta-roundyoutube-round

Need help?Sitemap

News·3 min read

Let's Unpack This: Should There Be Limits For Presidential Candidates?

fbtwitteremailpaper-clip

 The White House

October 7, 2024

Skimm'd by Rashaan Ayesh, Maria del Carmen Corpus, Marina Carver, Ana Rodriguez Martinez and Chantal Vaca.

Amid the growing calls for President Biden to drop out of the election, there’s another ongoing debate: Should there be an age cap for presidential candidates? We talked to Rose McDermott, a political scientist at Brown University. Here’s what she had to say…

What are the pros of having an age limit for presidential candidates?

There’s a minimum age: You have to be [at least] 35 to be president. Part of the reason the founders of the Constitution didn’t have an upper age limit is that nobody lived long [enough] to have to worry about somebody outliving their performance. But clearly, the founders were concerned about characteristics associated with age or they wouldn’t have had a minimum age … There are good reasons to be concerned about the age of leaders because there are certain illnesses that are much more likely [to develop] as you get older. Some of them are things like cancer, but a lot of them are also things that are concerning for decision-making, like Alzheimer’s.

I think the idea is not just whether or not you want an age limit or a series of tests that are required for somebody to pass … the idea is to protect the nation against the consequences that come with particularly devastating neurological diseases.

Is there any benefit to not having an age cap?

As people get older, they do increase in wisdom. It’s what you call crystallized knowledge, which is the ability to synthesize the information that you acquire across the course of a lifetime and apply it in new situations. There can be benefits to that. But that happens only when somebody isn’t also having an illness at the same time. That’s why something like cognitive tests might be useful.

Should there be a constitutional age cap for presidents?

Yes, I’ve argued that for a while … I think that the percentage of the population now that’s over 65 is … less than 20%. The problem is that once somebody gets above a certain age, they are no longer representative of the majority of the population, which is a lot younger.

Maybe at certain times, like in World War II, that didn’t matter so much. But now when you have pressing concerns — like climate change and AI — that are so tied to novel technologies and future problems, it’s just really hard to envision that somebody who’s generationally not representative of the majority of the population is the best choice … My one moment of hesitation [on the age cap] is that you can lose somebody who can be really valuable.

Featured Expert

PS: This interview has been edited for length and clarity.

Daily Skimm

Daily

The newsletter where millions of women start their day. Our unique take on what you should know — from oil prices to internet feuds — and what it means for you.

EmailSign up


See the latest issue

Read Next

Trump in front of a screen that says "100 days of greatness"

News·5 min read

What 17,000+ Skimm Readers Told Us About Trump’s First 100 Days

Image that reads "CDC Contraceptive Guidance for Health Care Providers"

News·7 min read

CDC Contraceptive Guidance Disappeared, So We Brought It Back, Too

theSkimm apostrophe logo

News·2 min read

Why You Need To Be Thinking About Menopause Early

Skimm the Vote

News·14 min read

Skimm the Vote 2024

 The White House

News·3 min read

What Is Project 2025? A Political Historian Answers Your Top Questions

Paid Family Leave

News·4 min read

Paid Family Leave: Why the US Falls Behind

Trending

Self Care·10 min read

These Adult-Friendly Fidget Toys Helped Me Cut Back on Doom-Scrolling

Amazon·13 min read

These Are the Best Deals at Amazon's Big Spring Sale

Kids·7 min read

Games, Toys, and Activities for Those Long Winter Days at Home

Money·4 min read

Tipping Guidelines From an Etiquette Expert

News·8 min read

ReproductiveRights.Gov Vanished, So We Brought It Back

fbtwitteremailpaper-clip

Follow us

fb-roundinsta-roundyoutube-round

Need help?Sitemap

© 2012-2026 Everyday Health, Inc., a Ziff Davis company. All rights reserved. theSkimm is among the federally registered trademarks of Everyday Health, Inc., and may not be used by third parties without explicit permission

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.