Northern Ireland (part of the UK) and Ireland (part of the EU) share a land border. And it’s one of the primary reasons Brexit has become the negotiation that never ends.
Brexit negotiations have been going on for over two years. One major holdup: What to do about the Irish border.
Ireland used to be one territory under British rule. But not everyone was into this arrangement, and in the early 1920s, Ireland was split in two. Southern Ireland, where the majority of people are Catholic, became the Republic of Ireland. Northern Ireland, where the majority of people are Protestant, remained part of the UK.
I’m sensing this is a story about religious tension.
Correct. In Northern Ireland, the Catholic minority felt they were being undermined by the local governments and police. And in the late ‘60s, they started staging civil rights protests that led to clashes with police. This kicked off decades of violence known as the Troubles, with fighting between Catholic and Protestant paramilitary groups, and clashes with British troops deployed to the area. Border checkpoints were frequently attacked. More than 3,500 people were killed in bombings, shootings, and other incidents. Skimm Notes gets into what this period was like.
So how did things end?
Both sides signed a peace agreement in 1998. It’s known as the Good Friday Agreement because, we’ll let you guess why. Northern Ireland would remain part of the UK but set up its own assembly – made up of both unionists who wanted to remain part of the UK and nationalists who didn’t – to make certain decisions locally. And border checkpoints between Ireland and Northern Ireland, which were by then both part of the EU, went away. Except...
The Big Issue
The tension never really subsided. To this day, many Catholic and Protestant neighborhoods in Northern Ireland are separated by fencing or walls. More than 90% of kids attend predominantly segregated schools. The area's history has made Brexit negotiations very (very very) complicated. Right now, the land border Northern Ireland and Ireland share is open and allows for the free movement of goods and people. Brexit means that could change. But there’s a lot of fear that bringing back a hard border will revive violence in an area where the peace is fragile.
So what’s the solution?
There’ve been a few proposals. Former Prime Minister Theresa May proposed that the UK would leave the EU, but remain part of the EU’s customs union and single market until the two sides negotiated a long-term trade deal that avoided setting up checkpoints along the Irish border. If they couldn’t reach a deal in a certain amount of time, the backstop would kick in. It meant that the UK would be tied to EU trade rules, potentially indefinitely.
You said former prime minister…?
About that. Pro-Brexit lawmakers – who under no circumstances want to remain part of the EU – voted down May’s plan. Three times. And she ended up resigning. Now it’s up to Prime Minister Boris Johnson to get Brexit done.
What’s his plan?
It keeps Northern Ireland as part of the UK’s customs territory. But it would still have to follow some of the EU’s trade rules. Although after a certain period, Northern Ireland lawmakers would be able to vote on whether to keep doing this. Still, some don’t like the plan because it treats Northern Ireland differently from the rest of the UK. UK Parliament eventually agreed in principle to Johnson’s deal but not to his fast-tracked timeline. Meaning the UK likely won’t leave the EU by the Oct. 31 Brexit deadline. Instead, Johnson requested a three-month extension. The EU agreed on a delay, but it’s not clear how long it’ll be. In the meantime, Johnson is calling on Parliament to approve an early election in December, in exchange for more time to read over his Brexit deal. He’s hoping that an election could give him more support to get his deal done.
It’s been over 20 years since the peace agreement that ended the Troubles. But Brexit negotiations have reminded the world what many Northern Irelanders have never forgotten: that the legacy of that violence still hurts. And that for all its global implications, Brexit also threatens to reignite a painful history on its home turf.
Sign up for the Daily Skimm email newsletter. Delivered to your inbox every morning and prepares you for your day in minutes.