We know what you’re thinking: a beach town? After Labor Day? But, rest assured, this is no mistake. Because, as many New Jerseyans will tell you, family-friendly Cape May is even better in the fall.
Sure, the weather is a bit cooler, but crowds flee, prices drop, and everything gets quieter — perfect for admiring the candy-colored Victorian homes, strolling the Cape May Promenade, hanging out at a local winery, and getting cozy at a charming boutique hotel (we’re partial to The Virginia). Not to mention, the water is technically still warm enough for the occasional dip — if that’s your thing.
🌅 Cape May’s pristine beaches are wonderful, but the area’s natural beauty extends beyond the shoreline. Rent a bike at Shields’, then cruise to Cape May Point State Park — home to scenic trails and the historic Cape May Lighthouse (the ocean and bay panorama is worth the 199-step climb) — and Sunset Beach, known for, shocker, its namesake views and “Cape May diamonds” (essentially, nature’s cubic zirconia). Or, for a different kind of ride, swing by Revolution Rail to rail-bike through marshes and meadows filled with monarch butterflies and migrating songbirds. Oh, and speaking of birds, Cape May has ranked among the world’s top bird-watching spots, so join a guided walking tour at Cape May Bird Observatory.
🛍 Whether you book a trolley tour or do your own thing, spend a day exploring the ridiculously quaint town. Start at Emlen Physick Estate to wander around the 147-year-old mansion’s meticulously restored rooms (warning: they may or may not be haunted), then make your way to Perry Street, Jackson Street, and/or Ocean Street — all of which have a high concentration of daydream-worthy Victorian homes. From there, head to Washington Street Mall, a three-block shopping district that includes standouts, like: Givens for chic clothes and accessories; Madison’s Bakery for outrageous sticky buns; and The Cheese Shop for, well, you know what.
🍴 Seafood is practically synonymous with any coastal city — and that’s certainly the case in Cape May. The Lobster House is a local institution serving up, yes, lobster, but also oysters and clams in five dining rooms and on a 130-foot-long sailing vessel moored dockside. Looking for something more upscale? Snag a seat at one of Beach Plum Farm’s family-style harvest dinners, featuring veggies, herbs, and meats from the 62-acre property. Finally, for the sweetest end to the evening, pick up a Peace Pie ice cream sandwich, stuffed with a layer of pie filling. We’ll give you a moment to process.